The 2026 FCS offseason is upon us, and it's time to dive into the top returning linebackers who will shape the upcoming season. This year's rankings are a fascinating mix of proven stars and emerging talents, each bringing their own unique story to the field. Let's explore the top 30 returning FCS linebackers and uncover the insights that make them stand out.
The Rising Stars
- Tye Niekamp, Illinois State
Tye Niekamp is a force to be reckoned with. His 2025 campaign was nothing short of legendary, as he led the FCS with 160 tackles, including 16 TFLs, 3.5 sacks, and an impressive array of defensive stats. With three-time All-MVFC selections and three-year All-American accolades under his belt, Niekamp is a veteran presence who continues to dominate. His ability to lead Illinois State to the national championship game further cements his status as one of the top linebackers in the FCS.
- Mikey D'Amato, Cal Poly
Mikey D'Amato's 2025 season was a testament to his talent. Earning First Team All-Big Sky and Second Team AP All-American honors, D'Amato was a tackling machine. With 137 tackles, 8.5 TFLs, and an impressive array of defensive stats, he finished No. 4 in FCS total tackles. His size and skill set make him a versatile player who can make an impact in multiple aspects of the game.
- Rohan Davy, Rhode Island
Rohan Davy's breakout season last year was a sight to behold. At just 5-foot-10 and 205 pounds, he was a disruptive force, totaling 101 tackles, 13 TFLs, seven sacks, and five quarterback hurries. His performance against FBS Western Michigan, where he recorded 12 tackles and two TFLs, showcased his ability to compete against top-tier competition. Davy's disruptive presence and impressive stats make him a player to watch in 2026.
The Veterans
- Peyton Wing, Montana
Peyton Wing's journey to Montana was a strategic move that paid off. After a stellar 2024 season with Portland State, he transferred to Montana and became a cornerstone of the defense. With 78 tackles, 8.5 TFLs, 3.5 sacks, and an impressive array of defensive stats, Wing earned All-Conference First Team honors and All-American accolades. His back-to-back All-Big Sky performances make him a veteran leader who can anchor the defense.
- Cole Taylor, Montana State
Cole Taylor's 2025 season was a surprise package for Montana State. Inserted into the starting lineup as a sophomore due to injury, he flourished with 107 tackles, 7.5 TFLs, three QB hurries, and two interceptions. Taylor's size and skill set make him a versatile player who can make an impact in multiple aspects of the game. His performance earned him a spot on the All-Big Sky Second Team, showcasing his potential for future success.
The Transfer Portal
- Geno Calgaro, Stony Brook (transfer from Saint Francis)
Geno Calgaro's transfer from Saint Francis to Stony Brook adds an intriguing dynamic. His ability to adapt to a new system and contribute immediately is a testament to his versatility and talent. With a strong showing in 2026, Calgaro could become a key player for Stony Brook's defense.
The Rising Stars (Continued)
- Jaiden Haygood, UTRGV
Jaiden Haygood's presence at UTRGV is a promising development. His ability to make an impact in a new system is a testament to his adaptability and talent. With a strong showing in 2026, Haygood could become a key player for UTRGV's defense.
- Moses Meus, Rhode Island
Moses Meus' journey to Rhode Island is a story of perseverance and talent. His ability to make an impact in a new system is a testament to his versatility and skill set. With a strong showing in 2026, Meus could become a key player for Rhode Island's defense.
The Takeaway
The 2026 FCS offseason is a fascinating time for linebacker prospects. From rising stars to veteran leaders, each player brings their own unique story to the field. As we anticipate the upcoming season, these top returning linebackers will shape the FCS landscape, leaving their mark on the sport and inspiring future generations of players.
